Below are three hands posted by
KingPrussia for review. I list the post identical to how he showed it to me. The comments throughout the hand (written to the right) are from him. I posted my analysis below the hand history.
Start at the top and read through the three hands. Think about if, when, and where this player made a mistake. How could he have fixed it? Sometimes we could've avoided making a mistake while playing poker if only we would've folded, raised, bet more, checked, just called, moved all-in, seen the trap, bet less, and so on...
I decided to look at these three hands because it's good not just to look back at the hands you play but to look at how the world (majority of people/average poker players) play hands. Usually it ends up with them calling too much and not folding enough, but maybe
KingPrussia is different.
His post starts now:3 hands within a 10 minute span.looking for evidence of poor play, poor bet sizes, etc. results included. thoughts appreciated. thanks.Hand #1 Full Tilt Poker Game #5833636632:Table Winery Ridge- $0.50/$1- No Limit Hold'em- 20:27:30 ET - 2008/03/29Seat 1: sagitarius09 ($47.80)Seat 2: benjikome ($151.05)Seat 3: BOASK ($92)Seat 4: samtan56 ($22.30)Seat 5: C YoNUTS ($31.50)Seat 6: Blind Supremacy ($27.35)Seat 7: KingPrussia ($131.80)Seat 8: rollthadice4 ($74.10)Seat 9: Poachey ($140.05)BOASK posts the small blind of $0.50 amtan56 posts the big blind of $1The button is in seat #2*** HOLE CARDS ***Dealt to KingPrussia [9d 9c]Blind Supremacy foldsKingPrussia raises to $3rollthadice4 foldsPoachey calls $3sagitarius09 foldsbenjikome foldsBOASK calls $2.50samtan56 folds*** FLOP ***[3d 9s Kd]BOASK checksKingPrussia bets $5Poachey calls $5BOASK folds*** TURN ***[3d 9s Kd] [Qd]KingPrussia bets $10Poachey calls $10*** RIVER ***[3d 9s Kd Qd] [2s]BOASK adds $11KingPrussia checksPoachey bets $10KingPrussia calls $10*** SHOW DOWN ***Poachey shows [6d 7d] a flush, King highKingPrussia mucksPoachey wins the pot ($57) with a flush, King highHand #2 Full Tilt Poker Game #5833652959:Table Winery Ridge- $0.50/$1- No Limit Hold'em- 20:28:54 ET- 2008/03/29Seat 1: sagitarius09 ($49.30)Seat 2: benjikome ($151.05)Seat 3: BOASK ($100)Seat 4: samtan56 ($20.80)Seat 5: C YoNUTS ($30.50)Seat 6: Blind Supremacy ($27.35)Seat 7: KingPrussia ($103.80)Seat 8: rollthadice4 ($74.10)Seat 9: Poachey ($169.05)C YoNUTS posts the small blind of $0.50Blind Supremacy posts the big blind of $1The button is in seat #4*** HOLE CARDS ***Dealt to KingPrussia [Ac 7c]KingPrussia calls $1 ollthadice4 folds Poachey calls $1sagitarius09 folds benjikome calls $1BOASK folds samtan56 calls $1C YoNUTS calls $0.50Blind Supremacy has 15 seconds left to actBlind Supremacy checks*** FLOP ***[8c 8d 6c]C YoNUTS checksBlind Supremacy has 15 seconds left to actBlind Supremacy checksKingPrussia bets $3Poachey foldsbenjikome calls $3samtan56 calls $3C YoNUTS foldsBlind Supremacy folds*** TURN ***[8c 8d 6c] [Jc]KingPrussia checksbenjikome bets $8samtan56 calls $8KingPrussia has 15 seconds left to actKingPrussia raises to $22benjikome calls $14samtan56 has 15 seconds left to actsamtan56 folds*** RIVER ***[8c 8d 6c Jc] [6d]KingPrussia checksbenjikome has 15 seconds left to actbenjikome bets $38KingPrussia calls $38 <== i know i'm beat but look him up*** SHOW DOWN ***benjikome shows [9c 8s] a full house, Eights full of SixesKingPrussia mucksbenjikome wins the pot ($140) with a full house, Eights full of SixesHand #3: Full Tilt Poker Game #5833744648:Table Winery Ridge- $0.50/$1- No Limit Hold'em- 20:36:41 ET - 2008/03/29Seat 1: sagitarius09 ($57.80)Seat 2: benjikome ($223.55)Seat 3: BOASK ($100)Seat 4: DarceD ($98.50)Seat 5: konsul8 ($98.50)Seat 6: Blind Supremacy ($26)Seat 7: KingPrussia ($47.80)Seat 8: rollthadice4 ($73.10)Seat 9: Poachey ($171.70)Blind Supremacy posts the small blind of $0.50KingPrussia posts the big blind of $1The button is in seat #5*** HOLE CARDS ***Dealt to KingPrussia [Ah Tc]rollthadice4 calls $1Poachey foldssagitarius09 foldsbenjikome foldsBOASK foldsDarceD has 15 seconds left to actDarceD foldskonsul8 foldsBlind Supremacy adds $0.50Blind Supremacy foldsKingPrussia raises to $3rollthadice4 calls $2*** FLOP ***[4c Qd As]KingPrussia checksrollthadice4 checks*** TURN *** [4c Qd As] [Kh]KingPrussia bets $3rollthadice4 calls $3*** RIVER ***[4c Qd As Kh] [Ts]KingPrussia bets $5 <=== prolly should c/c here?rollthadice4 raises to $14KingPrussia calls $9*** SHOW DOWN ***rollthadice4 shows [Jh Kd] a straight, Ace highKingPrussia mucksrollthadice4 wins the pot ($38.50) with a straight, Ace highHis post ends now. Hand 1 was fine.I'd like to see a bet a little over half the pot on the flop though. You bet $5, I say $6 or $7 is still cheap enough to draw in gut-shots/top pair and looks more like a continuation bet rather than a trap. The turn lead is good, make him pay to draw with QJ (inside straight on flop, pair on turn, dead to four outs against your set). The river was near perfect. I like check-calling in that spot as you did. Great hand... well, for minimizing losses. However, it seems as though the bad luck in hand 1 caused you to play worse in hands 2 and 3.
Hand 2 shouldn't have happened.You should fold A7s UTG at a large table. Four-handed is one thing, but UTG at a table of 7, 8, 9, or 10 players, A7s must be an auto-fold PF. You played this hand fine though until the river. When your opponent bet out and then called your re-raise on the turn, it is a big sign of strength both by him and you. This large amount of strength you showed throughout the hand would definitely deter him from trying to bluff you on the river.
With a board of 8-8-6-J-6 (3 clubs), your opponent could've had four hands (two beat you, two don't); eights full, sixes full, a smaller flush, and Jacks-up. If he had sixes full, he may have made a small value bet to get your flush to pay him off, and if he had eights full (which he did), he most likely would've bet big knowing he could essentially beat any hand that you check-call with.
The reason why you shouldn't have called his river bet is that he wouldn't have bet a hand worse than yours. The river would've scared his smaller flush (T9s) into checking, and he wouldn't have value-bet a Jack on a board that scary. You shouldn't have called the large river bet in this hand. Besides folding PF, if you would've check-folded the river, then you would've played this hand very well.
Hand 3 was not played bad until the river... again.This hand was a little different whereas both you and your opponent appeared much weaker, therefore making a bet from him more likely that it would be a bluff (due to him not raising any time during the hand and also thinking that you might be weak). Notice that I said "bet" and not "raise". His raise on the river should've have ended the hand for you as it seemed clear that he drew out on you by making Broadway.
Your river bet was not the best play. If you're capable of folding to a raise on the river, then a small value bet in hopes to get a worse hand like a smaller two pair to call you is not a terrible play. But you didn't bet small enough for any hand but a straight to call/raise you. Also, you didn't fold. It would've been a better play to bet small and fold to a raise on the river or check-call in attempt to induce your opponent to bluff bottom pair trying to represent a straight. Three hands... two wrongs and a right. I'd say you shouldn't have let the set of nines losing to a flush loosen you up and cause you to play worse immediately afterwards.
All that being said, the check-call on the river during your first hand shows great discipline and instincts for the game, as you felt that you may be beat even with such a strong hand and no raises from your opponent. Keep playing like you did in the first hand and you'll be on your way to great success!
-
Damian M. MoormanDayton2Vegas.com